Cookie Consent by PrivacyPolicies.com SLI - about us
Event

SLI Roundtable at EFI

Wednesday 5th February 2025

Discussion on ‘Future Pathways for Promoting Better Leadership Practice in Scottish Organisations’

The Scottish Leadership Institute with its remit to promote, advocate and convene to raise awareness and better practice of Human-Centred Leadership in Scotland, hosted this twohour open discussion with senior participants representing a variety of sectors and perspectives.

Scotland as a small nation is well-positioned to trial, experiment and ground-break new practices to enhance the leadership behaviour in its organizations.

There is a well-understood need to increase performance and productivity in all sectors across the nation, and leadership while not a ‘silver bullet’ for achieving that, is certainly a significant part of the solution. The question to tackle is what are the best ways to get managers and executives to embrace new practices, especially when time and funding is scarce, and other short-term priorities inevitably get attended to more urgently, pushing the engagement with leadership development down the priority list.

Participants

  • Nathalie Agnew – Chair, IOD Edinburgh & Lothians; MD Muckle Media
  • Dave Caesar – Associate Medical Director, NHS Lothian, formerly Head of Health Leadership & Talent Management, NHS Scotland
  • Robert Carr – Partner, Anderson Strathern and member of the Fair Work Commission
  • Kristy Docherty – Director Public Services, Edinburgh Futures Institute
  • Gary Gillespie – Chief Economist, Scottish Government
  • Judith Parke – Scottish Leadership Institute; and Director, the Wellbeing Outfit
  • Roddy Millar – Scottish Leadership Institute; Founder, Ideas for Leaders

Event summary

Key Ideas Discussed at the SLI Meeting

Collaborative Approach to Leadership

The meeting focused on leadership challenges and potential solutions in Scotland. Key points included the need for a collaborative approach to leadership and addressing systemic issues.

Importance of Dialogue and Collaboration

was placed on creating spaces for open conversations and supporting organisations to improve leadership and collaboration. The SLI aims to convene diverse perspectives to explore leadership issues and foster collaboration across sectors. Creating "safe, discretionary spaces" for open and honest conversations, free from hierarchical structures, is crucial.

Psychological Safety

Creating environments where people feel safe to speak up and admit mistakes is essential for better leadership. Many systems in Scotland, particularly in the public sector, operate with low levels of psychological safety.

Highlighting Good Practices

Identifying and showcasing examples of e􀆯ective leadership across all sectors is important. The SLI wants to highlight good leadership practices and amplify these examples to sow the seeds of change.

Implementation Focus

There is a need to shift the focus from simply identifying problems to actively implementing change. The SLI's focus is more on implementation rather than strategy, promoting a leadership mindset across the whole hierarchy of employees.

Humility and Courage in Leaders

Good leaders should be both humble and courageous.

Systemic Approach

Recognising that leadership challenges are interconnected requires a systemic approach, breaking down silos and encouraging collaboration.

Citizen-Centric Focus

More emphasis should be placed on the needs of the people that public services serve, rather than just organisational structures.

Barriers to Effective Leadership in Scotland

Hierarchical Leadership Models

Traditional, top-down leadership models hinder the development of leadership at all levels.

Siloed Working

A significant barrier is the tendency for organisations and departments to operate in silos.

Risk Aversion

There's a pervasive culture of risk aversion that discourages innovation and collaboration.

Lack of Reflection Space

Many organisations lack the time and resources to reflect on their leadership approaches.

Ideological Barriers

Deep-seated ideologies, particularly concerning public services, pose significant barriers to progress.

Lack of Awareness

Many Scottish organisations lack awareness of the need to pause and reflect on their leadership approaches.

Proposed Solutions

Creating Safe Spaces

Establishing neutral spaces for open conversations among diverse sectors.

Promoting Psychological Safety

Creating environments where individuals feel safe to speak up and admit mistakes.

Highlighting Good Practices

Showcasing examples of e􀆯ective leadership across all sectors.

Focusing on Implementation

Shifting the focus from merely identifying problems to actively implementing change.

Developing Facilitation Skills

Developing skilled facilitators to create inclusive spaces and guide discussions.

Four Actions to Take Forward

  1. Explore opportunities to create more "safe, discretionary spaces" for open dialogue and the exploration of new ideas, potentially involving cross-party political leaders.

  2. Identify and highlight good leadership practices and case studies across di􀆯erent sectors to inspire and educate others.

  1. Consider how to better reach and engage "harder to reach" audiences, such as small businesses and charities, in discussions around leadership and organizational change.

  2. Investigate ways to de-risk and depoliticise certain domains like healthcare and education to enable more systemic change.